Family: James Luther Ettinger / Mary Minerva "Minnie" Shaffer (F523)
m. Feb 1890 | Lieutenant Daniel E. Shaffer (1836-1864) |
| Sarah J. Meyer (1838-1900) 
|
Elizabeth Shaffer (1861-1938)  |
| James Luther Ettinger (1861-1936) |
| Mary Minerva "Minnie" Shaffer (1862-1909)
|
| Sarah A. Ettinger (1890-1989) |
| George Woodard Ettinger (1891-1964) |
| Eleanor E. Ettinger (1893-1901) |
| John Daniel Ettinger (1895-1927) |
| Charles Schaffer Ettinger (1896-1965) |
| Henry Clay Ettinger (1898-1953) |
| Margaret Ettinger (1902-2003) |